saw the acclaimed film *notes on a scandal* this week, and left the theatre with a whoah, what the hell was that all about? what a psychological clusterfuck of a film.
i won't re-hash the plot or really talk about the details of the film here. that info is widely available elsewhere. suffice it to say that this is a movie about obsessions, and moral failings.
what i liked about the film:
the performances. as most everyone has noted, this is an acting tour de force, with judi dench and cate blanchett sparring on screen in a vigorous, superb manner. judi dench is astounding as the frumpy loner, barbara. the twinkle in her eyes speak volumes, and she has created one of the most despicable ( very humanly so) screen characters in recent memory. cate blanchett is great too, but her character, sheba, isn't as nuanced or dynamic as dench's barbara.
the commentary on obsession. each of the characters is motivated by obsession. barbara is obsessed with sheba, sheba is obsessed with her young, student lover, and sheba's husband is obsessed with their seemingly perfect, bourgeois life. the movie reveals that all obsession, regardless of degree, leads one down dangerous paths, with, more often than not, dangerous outcomes.
the commentary on morality. this film notes that all people are flawed, and bad decisions, and obsessions lead one to committ bad deeds. barbara's flaws are most obvious, and the extent of them are slowly revealed in the film. sheba and her husband are the most interesting because, on the surface, they appear to have a picture perfect life. they are educated, do-good liberals who work as educators and have an adopted son with down's syndrome. their moral failings are not so apparant. as the film progresses we learn that sheba, a public school teacher, begins an affair with one of her 15 year old students. this morally questionable act leads her right into jail. her husband, we are led to believe, was once obsessed with sheba. he was her college professor who began dating her when she was only 20. thus, his character is shown to also be morally questionable.
the only weakness in the film was the plot. the "friendship" between the two women is hastily developed, as is the combustion between them at the end. the first three quarters of the film were well-paced and then the ending seems a bit too abrupt. but i'm being picky. it's not a bad film at all.
one question i have is about dench's character, barbara. is this woman the tired old lesbian trope? you know the type, the frumpy, evil, repressed lesbian who is out of possess, control and corrupt a younger woman in her midst? is barbara's sexuality that important to the film? she is repressed in every conceivable way, and doesn't seem to recognize that she is obsessed with younger women. one review (in the New Yorker, I think)suggests that dench's performance, and the multi-dimensional nature of this character prevent one from reading her as a stereotype. hmmm. don't know. i'm still thinking about that one.
go see it. if nothing else, for the acting clinic put on by dench and blanchett.
jb